Sotomayer’s decision on firefighters may be overruled by Supreme Court
In what may become a landmark case in employment discrimination law the Supreme Court is set to rule on the case of Ricci v. DeStefano by the end of this month. Making the case even more intriguing is that Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor, was on the three-judge panel that rejected the claim of three white police officers who argued that they were victims of racial discrimination when they were denied promotion.
Ricci deals with two provisions of the Civil Rights Act, which in essence contradict each other. One part of the Act states that no employee may be discriminated against because of his or her race, sex, religion or national origin. Another part of the Act exposes an employer to liable for using a hiring or promotional standard that has a “disparate impact on the basis of race,” unless it can be defended as a “business necessity.” During oral arguments, Justice Souter, whom Sotomayer is nominated to replace, commented that these two provisions put the employer in a “damned-if-you-do, damned-if-you-don’t situation.”
In Ricci, the city of New Haven decided to throw out the scores of white firefighters, who were taking the exams to be promoted, because it feared that a potential lawsuit when no black firefighters scored high enough to be promoted. The outcome of this case will prove to have profound effects on employment discrimination practices across the country.
